Author: Patrick Carman
Series: The Land of Elyon
Reading Level: Middle-grade (I'd recommend for 5th to 7th)
My Rating: 3/5 stars
Content Rating: PG
Alexa is 12 years old when she travels with her father
to Bridewell. She's lived her whole life behind the walls that protect
the major cities from the mysterious and dangerous things in the Dark
Hills. She's curious, though, about what lies beyond those walls. So
when a chance presents itself to find out, she takes it. She learns
about some sinister plots and a traitor in the city. Soon she isn't
sure who to trust.
Well. I'm torn. I had really high hopes for this one. And while it doesn't have bad language or any obviously inappropriate content, there were things that really bug me about it. And I'm hesitant to give the go-ahead to my 8 year old at this point. For one thing, Alexa, the main character, does a lot of lying. She's very sneaky, and while this is practically required to further the story, it bugs me. I also found one of the characters very creepy. And yeah, he's supposed to be her nemesis, so he's written to be that way, but I felt uncomfortable with an adult character whose interactions with a child were what they are in the book, at least initially. The character's name doesn't do him any favors either.
For me as
a reader, the book also felt really unbelievable. I can let that go,
though, as I'm obviously not the target audience. That said, I think
there are many middle-grade reads that are well-developed and believable
(even in the fantasy genre) even for adult readers.
I did like the author's message about the walls we build and whether or not we should.
In
the end, I have decided we'll keep the book on our shelves and give it a
couple years. This is strictly my feelings for my kids, and others may
feel differently.

